The Masonic Trowel

... to spread the cement of brotherly love and affection, that cement which unites us into one sacred band or society of brothers, among whom no contention should ever exist, but that noble emulation of who can best work or best agree ...

[What is Freemasonry] [Leadership Development] [Education] [Masonic Talks] [Masonic Magazines Online]
Articles] [Masonic Books Online] [E-Books] [Library Of All Articles] [Masonic Blogs] [Links]
What is New] [Feedback]

 Masonic quotes by Brothers

Search Website For

Add To Favorites

Help Me Maintain OUR Website!!!!!!

List of Contributors

PDF This File

Print This Page

Email This Site To ...

more light #335

Anti - Masonic Charges

by Ed Halpaus
Grand Lodge Education Officer
Grand Lodge of A. F. & A. M. of Minnesota

In the last issue of More Light I mentioned about some very negative comments posted on the U-Tube video received and how anti-Masonry is alive and well in the world today. Anti-Masonry is not something that existed only in the past, nor is it something we can, or should, ignore. The goal of the anti-Mason is to have Speculative Freemasonry cease to exist.

To understand the tactics and falsities of the anti-Masons the best book I can recommend on the subject is “Is It True What They Say About Freemasonry” by Brothers Art De Hoyos and Brent Morris. (It’s available at Amazon.) Another is “Workman Unashamed” by Brother Christopher ‘Kit’ Haffner. Another set of books I highly recommend to Masonic Students is “10,000 Famous Freemasons” by Wm R. Denslow; this set of books has been out of print for decades, but they can be found on the used book market (although they are expensive) and also as an e-book at Amazon. One of the better places to go to for used Masonic Books is Brother Harold Davidson of the Billings Masonic Library.

Some time ago I noticed a signature on the cover of the books of my set of the 10,000; it was “Mazzini,” so I looked him up in the book; his name is Giuseppe Mazzini. Reading about him in the 10,000 did pique my interest in learning more about him because he evidently was a very interesting Mason. He was a Past Grand Master of the Grand Orient of Italy. He was also a Lawyer who became a patriot and liberator of Italy. He lived from 1805 to 1882, and the story of his life is well worth reading.

In order to read more about him I turned to the Internet and typed his name into a search engine; One of the links that came up was truly an anti-Masonic site linking Mazzini to Albert Pike, and both of them to the Illuminati, and linking that to the ‘new world order’ the anti-Masons are so eager to say is what we Masons are up to establishing. It was after I began reading on the anti-Masonic site that I revisited “Is It True What They Say About Freemasonry?”; after reading in that book I turned to “Enemies Within; The Culture of Conspiracy in Modern America.” And the Short Talk Bulletin written by the author of the book – I mentioned these in the last issue of More Light.

Please bear with me while I seem to digress a bit on this book, it does have something to do with anti-Masonry, which complements the book by Brothers De Hoyos and Morris: In ‘Enemies Within’ on pages 22 & 23 the author begins writing about the “Red Scare of the 1950’s”[i] Robert Welch and the John Birch Society. He tells the reader that Welch studied history for secret patterns and intrigues, and he found what he could use “in a centuries-old master conspiracy of ‘insiders,’ for whom Communism was but one means to world domination. Evolving over decades, his work and that of like-minded counter subversives broke their sub-cultural confines to raise mainstream consciousness of the real menace – the conspiracy to create a New World Order.”

So from what I can tell the term New World Order, which the anti-Masons like to link to Freemasonry, was popularized by the John Birch Society in the ‘50’s, and came from a much older written work about communism. In 1961 Gallup Polls showed that only 8% of those who had heard of the John Birch Society had a favorable impression of them and that fully 59% of those polled had an unfavorable impression.[ii] This caused the Society to concentrate on keeping their members and planning for the future.

In 1964 Robert Welch told the members of the John Birch Society that “his focus on communist intrigue we misplaced; communism was merely a subplot of the master conspiracy.” Welch then focused on the writings of John Robison and the Jesuit Augustin de Barruel whose writings were after the French Revolution. “The revolution, they argued, was not rooted in poverty and despotism. Rather than a rising of the masses it was the work of Adam Weishaupt’s Illuminati, a secret society that plotted to destroy all civil and religious authority and abolish marriage, the family, and private property.”[iii] Robison’s contention was that “the fall of France had not satisfied Weishaupt, and he planned to use Masonic Lodges to sow intrigue across national borders.” So it appears to me that it was John Robison’s writings after the French Revolution that linked Freemasonry with the Illuminati. From all appearances the John Birch Society did not propound about the Masons being connected with the Illuminati, but in 1966 Welch claimed – “The Insiders hands are everywhere, and loyalty to God nation, and family were in rapid decline. America was in the Insiders grasp with ‘60 to 80 percent’ already lost. The conspirators had reached their endgame, with the United States about to become a province of the ‘New World Order.”[iv]

Here is where the book “Is it True What They Say about Masonry?” comes in, and where it is helpful. The anti-Masonic Web Site I mentioned is, and can be found at: and on that site are some interesting images of Brother Albert Pike and Brother Mazzini: It gives Brother Pikes years of life, 1809–1891, the article on Brother Pike begins by linking him to Brother Mazzini like this: “He [Pike] was chosen by Mazzini to head the Illuminati operations in America and moved to Charleston, South Carolina, in 1852.” This is interesting because in Denslow’s 10,000 Famous Freemasons it tells us that Brother Pike, two years after his third degree of Masonry, was a charter member and first Master of Magnolia Lodge #60, (November 04, 1852,)and it was March 20, 1853 when he received the degrees of the A.A.S.R.

What to me is also interesting is that according to Mackey’s Encyclopedia of Freemasonry,[v] the elector of Bavaria issued an edict for the suppression of the Illuminati on June 22, 1784, after which many if its members were fined or imprisoned and Adam Weishaupt, who founded the Illuminati, fled the country. The edict was repeated the next year and by the end of the 1700’s the Illuminati had ceased to exist. Some important facts to keep in mind here is that Brother Mazzini was born in 1805 and Brother Pike was born in 1809; at least 5 and 9 years after the Illuminati ceased to exist.

There are so many things that are interesting, such as; we know who founded the Illuminati and when, and we know what happened to it. However when we think about Freemasonry I think what M.W.B. Delmer David Darrah said: “No man discovered law or can locate its beginnings; no man invented education, or can name its birthplace; nor is it possible to state when religion took its place in the moral sphere of men. These great forces spring from the needs of the human soul, and are the result of growth and development. The same is true for Freemasonry. It was not created, but grew out of the past.”

Brother Mackey says: “Weishaupt connected it [the illuminati] with the Masonic institution after whose system of degrees, of esoteric instruction, and of secret modes of recognition, it was organized. It has thus become confounded by superficial writers with Freemasonry, although it never could be considered as properly a Masonic Rite.”

“Adopting Freemasonry only as a means for its own more successful propagation, and using it only as incidental to its own organization, it exercised while in prosperity no favorable influence on the Masonic institution, nor any unfavorable effect on it by its dissolution.”[vi]

Back to some information where the book “Is It True What They Say About Freemasonry?” can help. On the anti-Masonic web page it continues with charges by repeating false charges made by Leo Taxil by quoting from a book titled, Occult Theocracy, written by Edith Starr, in the 1930’s, under the pen name of Lady Queensborough. This book quotes and uses the hoax perpetrated by Gabriel Jogand –Pagés, who wrote under the pen name of Leo Taxil. Taxil’s entire confession about the Hoax’s he perpetrated concerning the Freemasons and the Catholic Church can be read in its entirety in Brother’s De Hoyos and Morris’ book: This book is worth every penny of the cost.

Given the information on the web site of the Bible Believers and the fact that they continually repeat incorrect, false, and documented hoaxes teaches the Masonic Student that it doesn’t hurt to research the charges of the anti-Mason; their charges and accusations about Freemasonry cannot stand up to even a cursory investigation, and certainly not to a thorough investigation. Freemasonry can stand up to investigation!

Something else we learn from the anti-Mason is how they use a very disturbing method to propagate their falsities about Freemasonry: In a conversation with the Minister of my church; the conversation touched on using only part of a scripture in a talk or article to make a point, he and I are both against this type of thing. When someone uses only part of something, or part of something along with something of another thing to make some text say something it doesn’t, this is called “Proof-Texting.”

In “Is It True What They Say About Freemasonry?” the authors spend some time showing how the anti-Masons ‘proof-text’ the writings of Brother Albert Pike in Morals and Dogma by actually leaving out portions of paragraphs to make Brother Pike’s writings say something that they don’t. This is a very interesting part of the book.

On the web site for Bible Believers the writer there does the same thing, but the writer takes ‘proof texting’ a bit further by inserting words in parentheses indicating that the author had the word in parentheses in order to explain his thought, when in fact the anti-Masonic writer put them in. So he or she is attempting to have the reader think Pike is saying something completely different than what he is actually saying.

Regarding Morals and Dogma – the anti-Masonic writer gives us this example

In this massive volume he explained that the “blind Force of the people is a Force that must be economized, and also managed. . . [Ed’s Comments - page 1-m only part of the sentence is quoted] [Actually two complete sentences are needed to put this in context.] it must be regulated by intellect. “To attack the citadels (Institutions) built up on all sides against the human race by superstitions (religion), despotisms, and prejudices, the force must have a brain and a law (the Illuminati’s). Then its (Force) deeds of daring produce permanent results, and there is real progress. Then there are sublime
conquests. . .[Pike’s words edited out - thought is a force, and philosophy should be an energy, finding its aim and its effects in the amelioration of mankind. The two great motors are truth and love.] When all forces combined, and guided by the Intellect (Illuminati), and regulated by the Rule of Right, and Justice, and of combined and systematic movement and effort, the great revolution prepared for the ages will begin to march. . . [Pike’s words edited out - The power of the Deity Himself is in equilibrium with his wisdom. Hence the only results are Harmony.] It is because Force is ill regulated that revolutions prove failures” Albert Pike, Morals and Dogma of the Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite of Freemasonry,[Ed’s Comments - this sentence is taken from the beginning of the next paragraph, which has to do with a different thought.][Here is the sentence that follows, as Pike wrote it – “Therefore it is that so often insurrections, coming from those high mountains that domineer over the moral horizon, Justice, Wisdom, Reason, Right, built of the purest snow of the ideal after a long fall from rock to rock after having reflected the sky in their transparency, and been swollen by a hundred affluents, in the magic path of triumph, suddenly lose themselves in quagmires, like a California River in the sands.” 1-2 (Rev. Ed. 1950). [Ed’s Comment - Actually page 1 L and continues to the top of page 2

[When referring to items and text in Morals and Dogma it is common to use 1m or 256L or 719u – meaning page # middle, page # lower, or page # upper. Knowing the page number and what part of the page to look for information is helpful, and that’s the way the book’s index is laid out.]

Suffice it to say that there are people out there who are anti-Masons who are doing whatever they can to tell lies about Freemasonry and Freemasons. They tell us we just don’t know what we’re involved with and that they do. And because they know they are going to tell us and our loved ones what Freemasonry is all about. Well if someone is going to tell your loved ones what Freemasonry is all about – it should be you. Get the book “Is It True What They Say About Freemasonry?” if you don’t have it already, also get a copy of Morals and Dogma with a good index (also available as an e-book now) and look things up when you hear about quoted portions of it, to see if it’s true. Read and learn about the Craft!

Unlike the unsubstantiated charges of the anti-Masons, Freemasonry can stand up to scrutiny and inspection.

In this day and age there is no reason for your loved ones to get false information about Freemasonry from our enemies. Believe it or not, doing the research into these false charges and lies the anti’s like to spread is enjoyable, because you learn more about Freemasonry in the process, and then you can share this knowledge with those you care about; your Brethren, your friends, and your family.


[i] Enemies Within by Robert Alan Goldberg pages 22 & 23

[ii] ibid Page 45

[iii] ibid

[iv] ibid page 47

[v] Clegg edition 1929 Volume 1

[vi] ibid

back to top

[What is Freemasonry] [Leadership Development] [Education] [Masonic Talks] [Masonic Magazines Online]
Articles] [Masonic Books Online] [E-Books] [Library Of All Articles] [Masonic Blogs] [Links]
What is New] [Feedback]

This site is not an official site of any recognized Masonic body in the United States or elsewhere.
It is for informational purposes only and does not necessarily reflect the views or opinion
of Freemasonry, nor webmaster nor those of any other regular Masonic body other than those stated.

DEAD LINKS & Reproduction | Legal Disclaimer | Regarding Copyrights

Last modified: March 22, 2014